Explore All In SEO
Recent Articles
Recent Articles
Recent Articles

12 Best Places Where To Sell Magic Cards For Make Money

Magic: The Gathering is a popular collectible card game that has captured the hearts of millions of players around the world. As the game continues to evolve with new expansions and sets, many players find themselves accumulating a vast collection of Magic cards. Whether you're a dedicated collector looking to downsize or a player seeking to trade or sell duplicate cards, finding the right platform where to sell Magic cards is essential. In this article, we'll explore some of the best places to sell Magic cards and make the most of your collection.

Keith Peterson
Keith Peterson
Aug 30, 202320.8K Shares359.9K Views
Jump to
  1. 12 Best Places Where To Sell Magic Cards For Make Money
  2. What Influences Magic The Gathering Card Prices?
  3. Tips For Selling Your Magic The Gathering Collection
  4. Is Selling Magic Cards Worth It? FAQ
  5. Where Can I Sell My Magic Cards Full Price? FAQ
  6. How Much Can I Sell MTG Cards For? FAQ
  7. People Also Ask
  8. Conclusion

Magic: The Gathering is a popular collectible card game that has captured the hearts of millions of players around the world. As the game continues to evolve with new expansions and sets, many players find themselves accumulating a vast collection of Magic cards.

Whether you're a dedicated collector looking to downsize or a player seeking to trade or sell duplicate cards, finding the right platform where to sell Magic cardsis essential. In this article, we'll explore some of the best places to sell Magic cards and make the most of your collection.

12 Best Places Where To Sell Magic Cards For Make Money

Complete Guide To Buying/Selling Magic Cards For Profit

If you're looking to turn your Magic card collection into some extra cash, there are several excellent platforms available to help you achieve that goal. Here are the 12 best places where you can sell Magic cards and make money:

  • eBay -As one of the largest online marketplaces, eBay provides a global audience for selling Magic cards. You can list individual cards or entire collections, set your own prices, and choose between auction-style or fixed-price listings.
  • TCGplayer - TCGplayer specializes in trading card games and offers a marketplace for Magic cards. It ensures competitive pricingand attracts a community of card enthusiasts looking to buy cards directly from sellers.
  • Cardmarket -If you're in Europe, Cardmarket is a popular platform for buying and selling Magic cards. It connects sellers with buyers from across the continent and provides a secure environment for transactions.
  • Local Game Stores -Many local game stores have buy lists where they'll purchase Magic cards for cash or store credit. It's a convenient option if you're looking for quick transactions.
  • Facebook Groups -There are numerous Facebook groups dedicated to Magic: The Gathering trading and selling. Look for groups in your region or with specific themes that match your collection.
  • Reddit -Subreddits like r/MagicTCG and r/mtgfinance have active communities where you can sell your Magic cards. Always follow the subreddit rules when posting.
  • Instagram -Create an Instagram account dedicated to showcasing your Magic card collection for sale. Use relevant hashtags and engage with the Magic community to attract potential buyers.
  • DiscordServers -Many Discord servers cater to Magic: The Gathering players and collectors. These servers often have dedicated channels for buying, selling, and trading cards.
  • Card Shows and Conventions -Attend local card shows, gamingconventions, or Magic tournaments to connect with potential buyers in person. These eventsoffer face-to-face interactions and networking opportunities.
  • Online Auction Sites -Aside from eBay, there are other online auction sites where you can list your Magic cards for bidding. Sites like Catawiki and Heritage Auctions might be worth exploring.
  • Buy lists from Retailers -Several online retailers offer buy list services where you can sell your Magic cards directly to them. They provide a list of cards they're interested in and their corresponding prices.
  • Magic Forums -Various Magic-related forums, such as MTGSalvation and MTG Nexus, have trading sections where you can list your cards for sale or trade with other members.

What Influences Magic The Gathering Card Prices?

Magic cards on a table
Magic cards on a table

The prices of Magic: The Gathering cards are influenced by a combination of factors that reflect the intricate interplay of supply, demand, gameplay, rarity, and collectibility. Understanding these influences can help players, collectors, and investors make informed decisions about buying and selling Magic cards. Here are some key factors that influence Magic card prices:

  • Rarity -Cards in Magic: The Gathering come in different rarities – common, uncommon, rare, and mythic. Generally, rarer cards are more valuable due to their scarcity. Mythic rares, in particular, often command higher prices due to their limited distribution within sets.
  • Set and Expansion - The set and expansion a card belongs to can significantly impact its value. Cards from older or out-of-print sets are often more valuable, as they are harder to find. Moreover, cards from powerful or popular sets can also see increased demand and higher prices.
  • Playability -Cards that see play in competitive formats, like Standard, Modern, or Legacy, tend to have higher prices. If a card is considered powerful, versatile, or a key component of winning strategies, its demand increases, driving up its price.
  • Metagame Shifts -Changes in the metagame (the dominant strategies and decks in competitive play) can greatly impact card prices. If a card becomes a staple in popular decks due to metagame shifts, its demand and value can surge.
  • Format Legality -Cards that are legal in multiple formats, such as Modern, Legacy, and Commander, often have more widespread demand and higher prices than cards limited to a single format.
  • Collectibility -Some cards have intrinsic value due to their historical significance, unique artwork, or the presence of foils, alternate art, or promo versions. Collectors are often willing to pay a premium for these items.
  • Condition -Card condition affects its value. Cards in near-mint (NM) condition are generally worth more than heavily played or damaged cards. Grading organizations like PSA offer professional grading services that can impact a card's price.
  • Supply and Demand - Basic economics play a critical role. If the supply of a card is low and the demand is high, prices will rise. Conversely, if a card is abundant and not heavily sought after, its price may remain lower.
  • Speculation and Hype -Rumors, spoilers, and speculation about upcoming cards, sets, or potential changes in the game can lead to price fluctuations. The hype generated around new cards or reprints can drive prices up temporarily.
  • Reprints -When a card is reprinted in a new set, its price can decrease due to increased supply. However, reprints can also introduce the card to a wider audience and affect demand.
  • Banlist Updates -If a card is banned or restricted in certain formats due to its power level or impact on gameplay, its value can plummet as its playability diminishes.
  • Promotions and Events -Magic events, such as Grand Prix tournaments, Pro Tours, or special promotions, can impact card prices. Cards that perform well in tournaments or are featured in promotional events can experience price spikes.

Tips For Selling Your Magic The Gathering Collection

3 Tips to Sell Your Magic the Gathering Collection for the Most Money

Selling your Magic: The Gathering collection can be a rewarding endeavor if approached with careful planning and consideration. Whether you're looking to downsize, fund new purchases, or simply transition away from the game, here are some tips to help you successfully sell your Magic cards:

  • Assess Your Collection - Before you start selling, take stock of your collection. Group cards by set, rarity, condition, and value. This will help you organize your selling strategy and make informed decisions about pricing.
  • Research Market Values - Research the current market values of your cards. Utilize online platforms like TCGplayer, Cardmarket, and eBay to get a sense of what similar cards are selling for. Consider both the lowest and highest prices to determine a reasonable range for your cards.
  • Prioritize High-Value Cards -Begin by focusing on selling your high-value cards. These cards are likely to yield the most significant returns and can help you generate funds for other endeavors.
  • Consider Card Condition -Be honest about the condition of your cards. Cards in better condition generally command higher prices. Use terms like "Near Mint," "Lightly Played," and "Moderately Played" to accurately describe the state of your cards.
  • Choose Selling Platforms -Decide where you'll list your cards for sale. Consider online marketplaces like eBay and TCGplayer, as well as community forumslike Reddit and Facebook groups. Each platform has its own audience and features, so choose the ones that align with your selling goals.
  • Create Detailed Listings -When creating listings, provide detailed descriptions of the cards. Include information about the card's set, condition, rarity, and any special attributes like foils or alternate art. High-quality images can enhance your listings and attract potential buyers.
  • Set Fair Prices -Set prices that reflect the current market value of your cards. Avoid overpricing, as this can deter potential buyers. On the flip side, avoid severely underpricing valuable cards.
  • Bundle Low-Value Cards -For lower-value cards, consider bundling them together. Selling cards in bulk can attract buyers who are looking to complete sets or add to their collections.
  • Communicate Promptly -Respond to inquiries from potential buyers in a timely manner. Good communication helps build trust and encourages buyers to proceed with their purchases.
  • Shipping Carefully -Package your cards securely to prevent damage during shipping. Use protective sleeves, top loaders, and padded envelopes or boxes. Consider using tracking and insurance for high-value cards.
  • Consider Selling to Stores -Local game stores and online retailers often have buy lists where they'll purchase cards from you. While the prices might be lower than individual sales, it can be a convenient option for quick transactions.
  • Be Open to Negotiation -Buyers may try to negotiate prices, especially for higher-priced items. Be open to reasonable negotiations, but also know your bottom line, and don't be afraid to decline offers that don't meet your expectations.

Is Selling Magic Cards Worth It? FAQ

Can YOU make money selling Magic cards the answer will surprise you

Is Selling Magic Cards Worth The Effort?

Selling Magic cards can be worth it if you have cards that you no longer need, want to make extra money, or want to reinvest in your collection. The effort required depends on factors like the cards' value, condition, and selling strategy.

Can I Make Good Money By Selling Magic Cards?

Yes, you can potentially make good money by selling Magic cards, especially if you have valuable or in-demand cards. However, the amount you make depends on the cards you're selling, their condition, market demand, and your selling methods.

Are Older Magic Cards More Valuable?

Older Magic cards can be more valuable, especially if they come from out-of-print sets or are considered iconic. Cards from older expansions are often sought after by collectors and players looking for nostalgic pieces.

How Do I Determine The Value Of My Cards?

You can determine the value of your cards by researching current market prices on platforms like TCGplayer, eBay, and Cardmarket. Be sure to consider factors like card condition, set, rarity, and demand.

Should I Sell My Cards Individually Or As A Collection?

The decision to sell individually or as a collection depends on your goals. Selling high-value cards individually can yield better returns, but selling bulk cards as a collection might be more convenient if you're looking to declutter quickly.

What Platforms Can I Use To Sell Magic Cards?

You can use online platforms like eBay, TCGplayer, Cardmarket, Reddit, Facebook groups, and local game stores with buy lists to sell your Magic cards.

Are There Risks To Selling Magic Cards Online?

Selling online comes with some risks, such as potential buyer disputes, shipping issues, or potential scams. To mitigate these risks, communicate clearly, package cards securely, use reputable platforms, and consider tracking and insurance.

Can I Sell Cards That Are Banned In Certain Formats?

While you can sell cards that are banned in certain formats, their value might be lower as they can't be used for competitive play. Collectors or players interested in casual formats might still be interested.

How Long Does It Take To Sell Magic Cards?

The time it takes to sell Magic cards varies based on factors like card rarity, demand, and pricing. High-demand cards might sell quickly, while others could take longer. Patience is key.

Are There Any Costs Associated With Selling Magic Cards?

Yes, there can be costs associated with selling Magic cards, such as platform fees, shipping costs, and potential fees for payment processing. Be sure to factor in these costs when determining your asking price.

Can I Trade Magic Cards For Other Cards Instead Of Selling?

Absolutely. Many players and collectors are open to trading cards for other cards they need or want. This can be a great way to diversify your collection without directly selling.

Should I Sell Cards I Might Regret Later?

Consider your long-term attachment to cards before selling. If you have sentimental value attached to certain cards, think carefully before selling them, as you might regret parting with them later.

Where Can I Sell My Magic Cards Full Price? FAQ

Need to Sell A Large TCG Card Collection? | An FDS How To

Is It Possible To Sell Magic Cards At Full Price?

Selling Magic cards at full price can be challenging, as most buyers are looking for deals or competitive prices. However, in certain situations or with the right buyer, you might be able to sell cards close to their market value.

Can I Sell My Magic Cards At Full Price On eBay?

While eBay is a popular platform for selling Magic cards, buyers often expect competitive prices. It's uncommon to sell cards at their full value due to market competition and buyer expectations.

Are There Specific Online Platforms Where I Can Sell Cards At Full Price?

While it's difficult to guarantee selling at full price, online platforms like TCGplayer, Cardmarket, and private collectors might offer better chances of getting closer to market value. However, competitive pricing is still common.

Should I Consider Selling Directly To Other Players?

Selling directly to other players through platforms like Reddit, Facebook groups, or local game stores might allow you to negotiate prices more directly. However, keep in mind that buyers will likely seek competitive prices.

Can I Sell Cards At Full Price To Local Game Stores?

Local game stores might buy cards at a fraction of their market value due to their need to resell and cover expenses. While it's convenient, you might not receive the full price for your cards.

What Factors Might Affect My Ability To Sell At Full Price?

Factors like card demand, card condition, rarity, market trends, and competitive pricing will influence your ability to sell at or near full price.

Can I Consider Trading My Cards For Their Full Value?

Trading cards for their full value can be challenging, as trades usually involve some negotiation and compromise. However, if you find a collector or player with specific needs, you might have a better chance.

High-value or popular cards might have a better chance of selling closer to their market value, but even then, competitive pricing is common. Research the market and be prepared for negotiation.

Are There Any Alternatives To Selling At Full Price?

Consider other options like trading, selling in bulk, or waiting for favorable market conditions to maximize your returns. Flexibility can help you achieve your goals.

How Should I Approach Pricing My Cards For Sale?

Research current market values on various platforms and set a reasonable asking price. While selling at full price might be challenging, setting a fair price increases your chances of attracting buyers.

How Much Can I Sell MTG Cards For? FAQ

Can You Make a Full Time Salary from Selling Magic the Gathering Cards

How Much Can I Sell My MTG Cards For?

The price you can sell your MTG cards varies widely based on factors like card rarity, set, condition, demand, and the platform you're using to sell. It's essential to research the current market value to get an accurate idea.

Where Can I Find The Value Of My MTG Cards?

Online platforms like TCGplayer, Cardmarket, and eBay provide current market values for MTG cards. These platforms consider recent sales data, card conditions, and demand to estimate prices.

Do All MTG Cards Have Value?

While not all MTG cards have high monetary value, many have some value due to factors like rarity and playability. Common cards might have lower values, but certain rares, mythic rares, and sought-after cards can be quite valuable.

What Factors Determine The Value Of MTG Cards?

Card factors such as rarity, set, condition, playability, demand in different formats, and collectibility all influence the value of MTG cards.

Are Foil MTG Cards Worth More Than Regular Ones?

Foil MTG cards are often worth more than regular versions due to their unique appearance. However, not all foils command significantly higher prices, and the value can vary based on the card's playability and collectibility.

How Can I Accurately Assess The Condition Of My Cards?

Card condition is graded from "Near Mint" (NM) to "Damaged." Cards in NM condition are worth more. Assess your cards honestly, and you can also seek guidance from professional grading services like PSA.

Should I Sell My MTG Cards Individually Or As A Lot?

High-value cards are usually best sold individually to maximize returns. For lower-value cards, bundling them as a lot might be more efficient, even if you don't get full individual card prices.

How Can I Avoid Undervaluing Or Overpricing My Cards?

Research is key. Look at similar cards on various platforms to get a sense of their market values. Balance your pricing based on card condition and demand.

Can I Sell MTG Cards For Cash Or Only Trade Them?

You can sell MTG cards for both cash and trade. Online platforms, local game stores, and collectors often offer cash options. Trading can also be a way to diversify your collection without direct selling.

Is It Possible To Sell MTG Cards Above Their Listed Market Value?

While it's less common to sell significantly above market value, in certain situations where demand is high or cards are scarce, you might find buyers willing to pay a premium.

Should I Negotiate Prices With Potential Buyers?

Negotiation is common, especially for higher-value cards. Be prepared to negotiate and find a middle ground that works for both you and the buyer.

Are There Any Fees Associated With Selling MTG Cards?

Selling on online platforms like eBay or TCGplayer might involve fees for listing and selling. Be sure to understand the platform's fee structure and factor it into your pricing.

People Also Ask

How Do I Know The Value Of My Magic Cards?

Determining the value of your Magic cards involves factors such as card rarity, condition, set, and demand. Online resources like TCGplayer, Cardmarket, and eBay listings can provide insight into the current market value of specific cards. Additionally, you can consult price guides or engage with online communities to get a sense of card valuations.

Where Can I Sell Bulk Magic Cards?

Selling bulk Magic cards can be done through various channels. Online marketplaces like TCGplayer and eBay offer options for selling larger quantities of cards. Local game stores might also have buy lists for bulk cards, and you can explore Facebook groups or subreddit communities dedicated to Magic: The Gathering for potential bulk sales.

What Is A Buy List For Magic Cards?

A buy list is a service provided by certain stores, both physical and online, where they specify the Magic cards they are interested in purchasing and the price they are willing to pay for each card. Sellers can consult these buy lists to see if their cards match the store's requirements and potentially sell their cards directly to the store.

Where Can I Sell Magic Cards For Cash?

You can sell Magic cards for cash through a variety of platforms. Online marketplaces like TCGplayer and eBay allow you to list cards for sale and receive payments via PayPal or other methods. Local game stores might offer cash for cards, and you can also explore community groups on platforms like Reddit and Facebook for cash transactions.

How Do I Ship Magic Cards When Selling Online?

When selling Magic cards online, ensure they are well-protected during shipping. Use protective sleeves and top loaders to prevent damage. Place the cards in a padded envelope or box and consider using tracking and insurance for valuable cards. Properly label and address the package, and communicate with the buyer to provide updates on the shipping process.


Navigating the labyrinthine landscape of Magic: The Gathering's card market can be a rewarding endeavor with the right approach. The diverse options for selling Magic cards, ranging from online marketplaces and local stores to community groups and events, offer a spectrum of possibilities tailored to individual preferences and goals.

By tapping into these insights and embracing the camaraderie of the Magic community, enthusiasts can not only maximize the value of their collections but also contribute to the ongoing narrative that has made this game a timeless and cherished pursuit.

Recent Articles